Annuity Lesson #38

Pros and Cons of MYGA Annuities

a happy senior couple celebrating an investment in annuities
Jeremiah Konger CEO Annuity Association

Jeremiah Konger

CEO

Share
Tweet

"An annuity may be particularly valuable for women who are concerned about outliving their money."

If low CD yields aren’t cutting it and protecting your principal matters more than ever as retirement approaches, it may be time to look beyond traditional options. One alternative worth considering is a MYGA (Multi-Year Guarantee Annuity), which offers a fixed interest rate and predictable, guaranteed returns over a set period.

That said, no financial product is one-size-fits-all. MYGA annuities come with trade-offs and may not be the right fit for every investor.

In this guide, we’ll break down what MYGAs are, their key advantages and limitations, and how they compare to other common financial strategies.

Key Takeaways


- MYGA annuities lock in a fixed interest rate for a set term and can offer higher yields than many bank CDs.

- They provide principal protection and tax-deferred growth, but have limited liquidity and surrender charges.

- Consider carrier strength, surrender terms, and your time horizon before choosing a MYGA.

What Are MYGA Annuities?

A MYGA (Multi-Year Guarantee Annuity) is a fixed deferred annuity that pays a guaranteed interest rate for a specific period, commonly 3–10 years. Unlike variable or index annuities, the credited rate on a MYGA is fixed for the contract term, providing predictable, insurance-backed growth. 

MYGA annuities can be a part of your broader retirement strategy, providing you with a consistent interest rate and predictable growth.

2026 Rate Snapshot 

Here is a rate snapshot of the best MYGA annuities so far:

ProviderProduct NameAM Best RatingSurrender PeriodEst. Fixed Rate*
Atlantic Coast LifeSafe Harbor
B++
3 - 205.80%
Read Review
Safe Haven3 - 205.45%
AmericoPlatinum Assure 5A5 5.15%Read Review

*Estimated fixed interest rates may change over time, and be based on your location

Important note: Estimated interest rates may change based on market conditions, insurer terms, age, and state of residence. 

The Pros: Why MYGA Annuities Are Trending in 2026

MYGA annuities are popular among pre-retirees for several reasons, including:

Guaranteed Yield for a Set Term

MYGAs lock in a fixed rate for the contract period. That predictability can be valuable when you want a known, guaranteed return on a portion of your portfolio without market exposure.

Tax-Deferred Growth

Interest in a MYGA grows tax-deferred. That can increase effective compounding compared with an interest-bearing CD that is taxed annually, especially if you’re in a higher income bracket and don’t need immediate access to that cash.  

Principal Protection

Because MYGAs are fixed insurance contracts, they protect the principal from market losses. If preserving capital is a primary objective, a MYGA can be an attractive option compared with market-based alternatives.

No Ongoing Management Fees

MYGAs typically do not charge annual management fees or advisory fees within the contract (though you may pay commissions at purchase depending on the advisor). There are no account management fees like those some investment products carry.

The Cons: What to Watch Out For

As with any investment, there are a few limitations you should be aware of before committing to MYGA annuities: 

Limited Liquidity and Surrender Charges

MYGAs usually impose surrender charges if you withdraw more than the permitted penalty-free amount during the surrender period. Surrender periods commonly extend several years, and charges decline over time. Read the contract to understand the schedule and any free withdrawal allowances.

Early Withdrawal Taxes and Penalties

Withdrawals before age 59½ may be subject to a 10% federal early withdrawal penalty in addition to ordinary income tax on earnings. This mirrors rules for many retirement accounts – plan withdrawals carefully.

Inflation and Fixed-Rate Risk

A fixed rate can lag inflation. If inflation rises substantially during your MYGA term, the real (inflation-adjusted) return may be negative. Consider laddering terms or diversifying your annuity contract to address inflation risk.

No Market Upside

Unlike an indexed or variable annuity, a MYGA won’t participate in stock market gains. If markets perform very well, a MYGA’s fixed rate can underperform market-linked alternatives.

MYGA vs. CD: Head-to-Head

a young woman saving up money for retirement

Tax

The tax difference between MYGAs and CDs really comes down to timing, and timing quietly does a lot of heavy lifting in long-term returns. 

With a MYGA, your interest compounds on a tax-deferred basis, meaning you don’t owe anything to the IRS until you actually take the money out. That allows the full balance to keep growing uninterrupted, which can make a noticeable difference over several years. 

CDs, on the other hand, operate differently. The interest is taxed every single year as ordinary income, even if you leave it in the account. 

Rates

MYGAs tend to offer higher fixed returns than CDs with similar time horizons. Insurers can do this because they operate under a different model than banks and are able to invest in longer-term assets. 

In exchange, you lock your investment in a set rate for a fixed period of time, typically between 3 and 10 years, depending on your annuity contract. 

Safety

CDs are backed by the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, which provides coverage up to established limits.

MYGAs, by contrast, are backed by the financial strength of the issuing insurance company, with an additional layer of protection from state guaranty associations. Hence, when choosing an annuity, you should always check the insurer’s strength and ratings. 

Immediate Annuities vs. MYGAs: Clearing the Confusion

People tend to confuse immediate annuities with MYGAs; however, these are two different products. 

A single premium immediate annuity (SPIA) is designed to turn a lump sum into a stream of guaranteed income that starts almost immediately, usually within a month or a year. Once you hand over the money, it’s essentially converted into payments. 

A MYGA, on the other hand, is a deferred fixed annuity designed for accumulation. Your money stays invested for a set term at a guaranteed interest rate, growing predictably but without generating income right away. 

How to Find the Best MYGA Annuities in 2026

Look for Strong Carrier Ratings

Choose insurers with solid financial strength ratings from agencies like A.M. Best. Rating quality matters more than chasing the highest advertised rate. A slightly lower rate with a stronger insurer can be a better option for capital preservation.

Examine Surrender Terms and Liquidity Features

Check the surrender charge schedule, penalty-free withdrawal allowances (some contracts allow 10% annual free withdrawals), and any rider features. Liquidity provisions vary widely; hence, it’s important to prioritize contracts that match your cash needs.

Compare Credited Rates and Contract Language

Always compare offered rates, how interest is credited, and what happens at term maturity (automatic renewal terms, grace periods, or notice requirements). Another key thing to remember is to confirm whether the rate is fixed for the full term and how renewals are handled.

Ask About Optional Riders and Fees

MYGAs are straightforward, but optional features or riders can affect liquidity or cost. If you are interested in customizing your annuity contract, confirm any rider fees and whether a rider is appropriate for your goals.

Summary: Is a MYGA Right for You?

MYGA annuities can be an effective tool for conservative savers who want a guaranteed, fixed rate for a set term and are comfortable with limited liquidity. They often compare favorably to CDs on an after-tax, risk-adjusted basis for investors who don’t need immediate access to funds. 

Get in touch with Annuity Association advisor to evaluate whether a MYGA annuity is the right investment for your retirement plan. We will help you compare current rates and match contract features to your timeline and financial goals.

NEED HELP? WE GOT YOU COVERED!

FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS

You can lose value only if you withdraw during the surrender period and incur charges. If you hold to maturity, the guaranteed principal and credited interest are paid per the contract.

At maturity, you’ll typically have options: take the contract value in cash, renew the contract at a new rate, or perform a 1035 exchange into another annuity.

Earnings inside a MYGA grow tax-deferred. When you withdraw earnings, they’re taxed as ordinary income. Principal withdrawals are generally tax-free until earnings are withdrawn. 

Many MYGAs have minimums around $10,000, though some insurers offer lower minimums. Check the specific product description for the exact requirements. 

Jeremiah Konger CEO Annuity Association

Annuity Expert

Jeremiah Konger

PS - Here's 3 ways we can help you learn more about annuities.

 

1. Watch Videos on How to Identify The Highest Paying Protected Income & Growth Annuities.

 

2. Watch Videos That Reveal What to Look For When Buying A Protected Growth Annuity.

 

3. Click Here To Access Our Annuity Review Vault To Compare The Pro's and Con's of Dozens of Annuities.

Annuity Association is the leader in providing Independent Annuity recommendations for protected income, safe growth and other benefits in retirement.

Annuity Association

759 SW Federal Hwy Ste 200H

Stuart, FL 34994

© Copyright 2026 by Annuity Association. All Rights Reserved.