Annuity Lesson #39
What is a Market Value Adjustment (MVA)? A Simple Explanation
Jeremiah Konger
CEO
"An annuity may be particularly valuable for women who are concerned about outliving their money."
You are reviewing a fixed or MYGA annuity, and you spot the words "market value adjustment" in the fine print. Your first instinct is right: this is something worth understanding before you sign. The term sounds technical, and when you cannot find a clear explanation, it is easy to assume the worst.
An MVA annuity clause is not a penalty in the traditional sense, but depending on what happens to interest rates after you purchase your annuity, it can reduce the amount you receive if you need to access funds before the contract term ends.
Most buyers hear about it briefly during the sales conversation but never get a complete picture of exactly when it applies, how much it can affect a withdrawal, and that it can sometimes work in their favor.
This article explains the MVA in plain language, covers both directions it can move, and helps you decide what it means for your retirement planning.
Confused by MVA and other annuity clauses?
Key Takeaways
- A market value adjustment (MVA) is a contractual provision that adjusts your surrender value up or down based on changes in interest rates since your purchase date.
- If rates have risen since you bought the annuity, the MVA reduces your withdrawal amount. If rates have fallen, it can increase your withdrawal amount.
- The MVA only applies to withdrawals above your free withdrawal allowance made before the end of the surrender period.
- It does not apply to required minimum distributions (RMDs), death benefits, or withdrawals made after the surrender period ends.
- For buyers who plan to hold the annuity to term, the MVA is largely irrelevant.
What Is a Market Value Adjustment (MVA)?
A market value adjustment (MVA) is a contractual provision found in some fixed and MYGA (multi-year guaranteed annuity) products. It adjusts the amount you receive from an early surrender or excess withdrawal based on the difference between interest rates at the time of purchase and at the time of withdrawal.
In other words, MVA in an annuity is a rule that can change your payout if you take money out early, depending on whether interest rates have gone up or down since you bought the annuity.
It is not a fee charged by the insurance company. It reflects the current value of your contract based on how interest rates have changed since you purchased it.
The clearest analogy is selling a bond before it matures. If you buy a bond paying 3.5% and then try to sell it when new bonds are paying 5%, a buyer will only purchase your bond at a discount because they can earn more elsewhere.
The same logic applies here. Your fixed annuity is backed by similar long-term investments, and the MVA reflects that same dynamic. The difference is that, unlike a bond sale, the adjustment can also move in your favor if rates have fallen since your purchase date.
How the MVA Works: Two Scenarios
The MVA can move in either direction, and grasping both scenarios is essential before evaluating any fixed annuity contract. Most of the anxiety around this provision stems from hearing only about the downside. The complete picture is more balanced than many buyers realize.
Scenario A: Rates Rise
In this scenario, interest rates have increased since your purchase date. For example, if your annuity was issued at a 3.5% credited rate and current rates are 5.0%, your contract is worth less in comparison because new contracts offer higher returns.
If you withdraw more than your free withdrawal amount during the surrender period, the MVA will reduce what you receive. The reduction may range from a few hundred to a few thousand dollars, depending on the carrier’s formula, the withdrawal amount, and how much rates have changed.
Scenario B: Rates Fall
In this scenario, interest rates have decreased since your purchase date. For example, if your annuity was issued at 3.5% and current rates are 2.0%, your contract is more valuable compared to new contracts offering lower returns.
In this case, the MVA may increase your withdrawal amount, since your contract is worth more in the current rate environment.
The MVA is not a one-sided penalty, but a mechanism that tracks the real economic value of your contract. The table below compares both scenarios side-by-side:
| Scenario A: Rates Rise | Scenario B: Rates Fall | |
|---|---|---|
| Rate environment at purchase | 3.5% crediting rate | 3.5% crediting rate |
| Rate environment at withdrawal | 5.0% (rates have risen) | 2.0% (rates have fallen) |
| MVA effect on withdrawal | Negative — reduces surrender value | Positive — increases surrender value |
| Why? | Your older, lower-rate contract is worth less relative to what new buyers can now earn | Your above-market rate contract is more valuable than what new buyers can earn today |
| Illustrative impact on $20,000 withdrawal | Withdrawal may be reduced by several hundred to a few thousand dollars, depending on the carrier's formula | Withdrawal may be increased — sometimes by several hundred dollars |
*All values are illustrative. Actual MVA impact depends on your carrier's formula and current market conditions.
When Does the MVA Apply — And When Does It Not?
One of the most important things to understand about the market value adjustment is that it does not apply to every transaction. Knowing when it is triggered and when it is not can help you plan withdrawals in a way that avoids unnecessary exposure to the adjustment.
The MVA applies when you make a withdrawal above your annual free withdrawal amount during the surrender period. If you surrender the contract entirely before the surrender period ends, the MVA will also apply to the full surrender value.
Note: Free withdrawal allowances vary by carrier and contract, so it is important to confirm the specific threshold in your own contract rather than assuming a standard figure applies (e.g., 10% of the contract value per year).
However, there are several situations in which most carriers expressly exempt the policyholder from the MVA:
- Required minimum distributions (RMDs) are generally exempt, which is an important protection for older contract holders who must take annual withdrawals from tax-deferred accounts.
- Death benefit payouts to beneficiaries are also typically excluded, as are withdrawals made after the surrender period has ended.
- Full annuitization, the process of converting the contract into a stream of income payments, is usually exempt as well.
Because contract terms vary by carrier, it is always worth confirming the specific exemptions in your contract or with your advisor before making any large withdrawal.
MVA vs. Surrender Charge: What Is the Difference?
Many readers confuse the MVA with the surrender charge because both apply to early withdrawals. However, they are two different mechanisms, and understanding the difference helps avoid misjudging your actual costs.
A surrender charge is a fixed percentage that declines over time according to a set schedule, such as 8% in year one, 7% in year two, 6% in year three, and so on. It always reduces your withdrawal and disappears after the surrender period ends.
The MVA, on the other hand, is based on interest rate changes. It can either reduce or increase your withdrawal depending on market conditions. Both can apply to the same withdrawal at the same time, making early withdrawals more costly when interest rates have risen.
The table below summarizes the differences:
| Surrender Charge | Market Value Adjustment (MVA) | |
|---|---|---|
| What triggers it | Any withdrawal above the free withdrawal amount during the surrender period | Any withdrawal above the free withdrawal amount during the surrender period |
| Direction | Always reduces withdrawal (always negative) | Can reduce OR increase withdrawal (negative or positive) |
| How calculated | Fixed percentage schedule declining over time (e.g., 8%, 7%, 6%...) | Based on the difference between the purchase rate and the current rate (varies by carrier) |
| When it ends | At end of surrender period | At end of surrender period |
| Can they stack? | Yes — both may apply simultaneously to the same withdrawal | Yes — both may apply simultaneously to the same withdrawal |
Not sure whether an MVA annuity is the right structure for your retirement savings? Our fiduciary advisors compare fixed and MYGA products across 80+ carriers, including products with and without MVA provisions, at no cost and no obligation.
Should the MVA Change Your Decision to Buy a Fixed Annuity?
For most buyers, the answer depends almost entirely on how you intend to use the product.
- The MVA is largely a background provision if
You are purchasing a fixed or MYGA annuity as a long-term, buy-and-hold vehicle, and you have no intention of accessing more than the annual free withdrawal amount before the surrender period ends.
It will not affect your credited interest, your principal protection, or your contract value as it grows. In that context, the MVA is a minor consideration, not a reason to avoid the product.
- The MVA is more relevant if
You are unsure about your short-term liquidity needs or think there is a realistic chance you may need to withdraw more than the annual free withdrawal amount before the surrender period ends.
In that situation, the MVA becomes an important factor to understand, especially in a rising interest rate environment, where it can increase the impact of the surrender charge.
It is worth planning around this risk in advance. Maintaining a separate emergency fund outside the annuity is the simplest way to reduce exposure. You can also ask your advisor about shorter surrender periods or non-MVA alternatives, even if they come with slightly lower credited rates.
The key trade-off is between a higher credited rate on an MVA product and reduced flexibility if you need early access to funds. This should be evaluated based on your personal liquidity situation before committing.
Bottom Line
A market value adjustment is not a trick or a hidden penalty. It is a disclosed contractual provision that aligns the value of an early surrender with the real-world interest rate environment at the time of that surrender.
It can reduce what you receive when rates have risen, and it can increase what you receive when rates have fallen. For buyers who hold their contract to term and stay within their free withdrawal allowance, it is rarely a factor. For buyers who may need liquidity before the surrender period ends, it deserves careful attention alongside the surrender charge schedule.
The MVA is one of several provisions that can significantly affect how a fixed annuity performs outside its normal hold period. Getting independent, fiduciary guidance before you sign ensures every clause is clearly understood and that the product genuinely fits your retirement plan.
Call (855)-866-3659 or schedule an online consultation with Annuity Association to clear any doubts you may have about your annuity.
NEED HELP? WE GOT YOU COVERED!
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
What Does MVA Mean on an Annuity Contract?
MVA stands for market value adjustment. It is a clause in some fixed and MYGA annuity contracts that can increase or decrease the amount you receive on a surrender or excess withdrawal based on how interest rates have moved since your purchase date. It is a disclosed contractual provision, not a hidden fee.
Can the Market Value Adjustment Actually Increase My Withdrawal Amount?
Yes. If interest rates have fallen since you purchased your annuity, the MVA works in your favor. Your contract is paying a rate that is now above what new buyers can earn, which makes it relatively more valuable. In that scenario, the adjustment increases the amount you receive on an early withdrawal rather than reducing it.
Do All Fixed Annuities Have a Market Value Adjustment?
No. Some carriers offer fixed annuities without an MVA provision. These products typically carry a slightly lower credited rate in exchange for removing the rate-alignment risk on early withdrawals. Whether the trade-off makes sense depends on your individual liquidity needs and how long you intend to hold the contract.
Does the MVA Apply to My Required Minimum Distributions?
Most carriers exempt required minimum distributions (RMDs) from the market value adjustment. This is an important protection for holders of tax-deferred annuity contracts who must take annual distributions once they reach the applicable RMD age. That said, contract terms vary by carrier, so confirming this exemption in your specific contract is always advisable.
How Is the Market Value Adjustment Calculated?
Each insurance carrier uses a proprietary formula, typically comparing an index rate at the time of purchase to the same index rate at the time of the withdrawal. Because methodologies differ across carriers, no single formula applies universally. Your carrier's contract document will describe the specific method used, and an independent advisor can help you interpret it.
Is a Fixed Annuity with an MVA Better or Worse Than One Without?
Neither is inherently better. MVA products often offer higher credited rates in exchange for the rate-alignment provision. For buyers who plan to hold the annuity to term and stay within their free withdrawal allowance, the MVA is unlikely to have any practical impact. For buyers with uncertain liquidity needs, a non-MVA product may provide more flexibility, even at a modestly lower rate.
Annuity Expert
Jeremiah Konger
PS - Here's 3 ways we can help you learn more about annuities.
1. Watch Videos on How to Identify The Highest Paying Protected Income & Growth Annuities.
2. Watch Videos That Reveal What to Look For When Buying A Protected Growth Annuity.
3. Click Here To Access Our Annuity Review Vault To Compare The Pro's and Con's of Dozens of Annuities.
Annuity Association is the leader in providing Independent Annuity recommendations for protected income, safe growth and other benefits in retirement.
Annuity Association
759 SW Federal Hwy Ste 200H
Stuart, FL 34994
Useful Links
About Annuity Associacion
© Copyrights 2025 by Annuity Association. All Rights Reseved.