Annuity Lesson #25
What Is a 1035 Exchange? Rules, Transfer Types, and When It Makes Sense
Jeremiah Konger
CEO
"Tax deferral is valuable, but it should never be the sole reason for replacing an existing annuity."
A 1035 exchange is a provision under IRS Section 1035 of the Internal Revenue Code that allows you to transfer an existing annuity or life insurance contract into another eligible contract without immediately paying income tax on accumulated gains. This tax-free transfer preserves tax deferral because the funds move directly between insurance companies rather than through a withdrawal. However, surrender charges and lost contract guarantees can outweigh the benefits of switching.
Your existing annuity may no longer offer the returns, flexibility, or income features you originally expected. Whether you’re holding a maturing multi-year guaranteed annuity (MYGA) or an older variable annuity with high fees, a 1035 exchange annuity strategy could help you move into a more suitable contract without immediately triggering income tax on accumulated gains.
However, switching contracts involves more than finding better terms. Surrender charges, lost guarantees, and new contractual restrictions can reduce or eliminate the financial advantages. Withdrawing your money before purchasing another annuity could also create an avoidable tax liability.
Annuity Association helps you evaluate these trade-offs through independent, fiduciary guidance. By comparing products from more than 80 insurance carriers, its advisors can assess whether a 1035 annuity exchange genuinely improves your retirement strategy or whether keeping your existing contract makes better financial sense.
Key Takeaways
- A 1035 exchange allows you to transfer the value of an eligible annuity or life insurance contract into another qualifying contract without immediately paying income tax on accumulated gains, provided the exchange meets IRS Section 1035 requirements.
- A 1035 exchange annuity-to-annuity transfer may benefit owners of underperforming, high-fee, or maturing contracts who want improved terms while preserving tax deferral.
- Under 1035 exchange rules, the IRS permits qualifying life insurance-to-life insurance, life insurance-to-annuity, annuity-to-annuity, and certain qualified long-term care insurance exchanges. However, an annuity cannot be exchanged for a life insurance policy under Section 1035.
- Surrender charge avoidance is not guaranteed. Existing surrender penalties, lost contract benefits, and new surrender periods can outweigh the financial advantages of switching.
- Annuity Association recommends evaluating the complete financial impact before exchanging contracts. Its independent fiduciary advisors compare surrender costs, existing guarantees, and replacement benefits to determine whether an exchange supports your long-term retirement goals.
What Is a 1035 Exchange and How Does Section 1035 Work?
A 1035 exchange is a tax-advantaged transaction that allows you to replace an eligible life insurance policy or annuity contract with another qualifying contract without immediately paying income tax on accumulated gains.
Authorized under Internal Revenue Code Section 1035, this provision helps policyholders update their financial arrangements while maintaining the tax benefits associated with their existing contracts.
The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) recognizes that insurance and retirement income needs can change over time. An annuity purchased years ago may carry higher fees, offer less flexibility, or provide benefits that no longer align with your retirement objectives. Section 1035 allows qualifying contracts to be exchanged without treating the transaction as an ordinary taxable withdrawal.
A 1035 exchange is a transfer between insurance companies, not a withdrawal. Done correctly, the money never passes through your hands, which is exactly why it stays tax-free.
How a 1035 Exchange Preserves Tax Deferral
The distinction between a transfer and a withdrawal is fundamental to understanding what a 1035 exchange is and how it works. In a properly executed exchange, the value of your existing contract moves directly to the replacement insurance company. You do not receive the funds personally, allowing the accumulated gains to retain their tax-deferred status.
For example, suppose your existing annuity has accumulated investment gains over several years. Surrendering the contract for cash could trigger income tax on those gains. However, transferring the contract’s value through a qualifying exchange generally allows you to postpone that tax liability until you eventually receive taxable distributions.
What Happens to Your Original Cost Basis?
Your cost basis generally represents the amount of money you originally contributed to an annuity using after-tax funds. This amount matters because it helps determine which portion of future distributions may be taxable.
During a qualifying exchange, your original cost basis generally carries over to the replacement contract. The transaction does not erase previously accumulated gains or establish an entirely new tax basis simply because you selected a different insurance provider.
Preserving these tax attributes can make an exchange useful when your current contract no longer meets your needs. However, the tax benefits alone do not establish whether switching is financially worthwhile.
For a closer look at how these rules affect future withdrawals, see our guide to how annuities are taxed.
How Does a 1035 Exchange Work, Step by Step?
A 1035 exchange annuity-to-annuity transfer works by moving the value of your existing contract directly from one insurance carrier to another, without the funds passing through your personal bank account. This direct transfer is essential for preserving the tax-deferred treatment available under Section 1035.
Although the process involves several administrative steps, the receiving insurance company typically coordinates the exchange with your existing provider. Understanding each stage helps you avoid unnecessary delays, incomplete paperwork, and potentially costly tax mistakes.
Who Initiates the Transfer?
The receiving insurance company generally initiates the exchange after you select a replacement contract and authorize the transaction. Your financial advisor can help compare available products, review potential surrender charges, and confirm whether the proposed replacement meets your retirement objectives.
Exploring fixed index annuity reviews can also help you understand the features and limitations of potential replacement contracts.
The process generally follows these steps:
- Review your existing contract. Identify surrender charges, accumulated gains, guaranteed benefits, and any restrictions affecting the transfer.
- Select a replacement annuity. Compare fees, income options, guarantees, and surrender periods before committing.
- Complete the exchange paperwork. Submit the application and required authorization documents to the receiving carrier.
- Transfer the contract value. The receiving carrier coordinates directly with your existing insurer to obtain the eligible funds.
- Confirm the replacement contract. Review the issued policy and verify that the transferred value and relevant tax information have been recorded correctly.
What Paperwork Is Involved?
The primary document is the 1035 exchange form, which authorizes the transfer between insurance companies. Depending on the carriers involved, you may also need a replacement annuity application, existing policy information, identification documents, and additional disclosure forms.
Your receiving carrier typically provides the necessary paperwork and explains its submission requirements. Accurate ownership information is particularly important because changes to the contract owner or other parties can affect whether the transaction qualifies for favorable tax treatment.
How Long Does a 1035 Exchange Take?
A 1035 exchange typically takes several weeks, although processing times vary between insurance companies. Delays may occur when documentation is incomplete, surrender restrictions require additional review, or the existing carrier needs further authorization.
You should continue monitoring your existing contract until the transfer is complete and the replacement insurer confirms receipt of the funds. Avoid independently withdrawing or depositing the money during this period, as doing so could jeopardize the intended tax treatment.
For additional guidance on qualifying insurance contract exchanges, see the IRS guidance on annuity income.
What Types of 1035 Exchanges Does the IRS Allow?
The IRS permits several types of 1035 exchanges involving life insurance, annuities, and qualified long-term care insurance contracts. However, not every combination qualifies for tax-free treatment. The direction of the exchange matters because Internal Revenue Code Section 1035 establishes which replacement contracts are eligible.
Generally, qualifying exchanges allow policyholders to move between certain insurance products without recognizing accumulated gains as taxable income at the time of transfer. These rules are designed to preserve existing tax advantages rather than allow every type of insurance contract to be exchanged freely.
Permitted vs. Prohibited 1035 Transfers
The following table summarizes the principal exchange types recognized under Section 1035.
| From → To | Allowed? | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Life Insurance → Life Insurance | Yes | Replace an existing policy with another qualifying life insurance contract. |
| Life Insurance → Annuity | Yes | Convert eligible life insurance value into an annuity while preserving tax deferral. |
| Annuity → Annuity | Yes | Transfer an existing annuity into another qualifying annuity contract. |
| Life Insurance or Annuity → Qualified Long-Term Care Insurance | Yes | Exchange eligible contract value for qualifying long-term care coverage. |
| Annuity → Life Insurance | No | Section 1035 does not permit this exchange direction. |
Exchanging Life Insurance for an Annuity
A 1035 exchange life insurance-to-annuity transaction allows an eligible cash-value life insurance policy to be exchanged for an annuity without immediately recognizing accumulated gains for income tax purposes.
This may appeal to someone whose financial priorities have shifted from providing a death benefit toward generating retirement income.
However, exchanging life insurance for an annuity means surrendering the original policy’s death benefit and potentially other valuable protections. Before proceeding, consider whether your beneficiaries still depend on that coverage and whether the replacement annuity adequately supports your financial objectives.
Why Annuity-to-Life Insurance Exchanges Are Prohibited
Although a 1035 exchange annuity-to-annuity transfer is permitted, the reverse movement from an annuity into life insurance is not. Section 1035 generally allows certain exchanges into contracts with comparable or more limited tax-advantaged features, but it does not authorize every movement between product categories.
Life insurance policies offer distinct tax advantages, particularly concerning qualifying death benefits. Allowing annuity values to move into life insurance without recognizing accumulated gains could extend favorable tax treatment beyond the exchange types Congress authorized.
These restrictions make it essential to verify eligibility before initiating any transfer. An independent advisor can help assess whether your proposed replacement qualifies under IRS rules and whether the exchange makes financial sense beyond its immediate tax treatment.
1035 Exchange Rules: Cost Basis, the Same-Owner Rule, and Partial Exchanges
The 1035 exchange rules require qualifying contracts to meet specific IRS conditions concerning ownership, tax basis, and how funds are transferred. Although exchanging an annuity can preserve tax deferral, overlooking these requirements may result in unexpected taxes or an exchange that fails to qualify under Section 1035.
Three areas deserve particular attention: preserving your original investment, maintaining consistent contract ownership, and understanding the additional restrictions on partial exchanges. Each can affect how your replacement contract is treated for federal income tax purposes.
How Does a 1035 Exchange Affect Your Cost Basis?
Your cost basis is generally the amount of money you contributed to an annuity using after-tax funds. For example, if you originally invested $80,000 and your contract subsequently grew to $105,000, your cost basis would generally be $80,000, assuming no adjustments from previous withdrawals or other transactions.
Under the 1035 exchange cost basis rules, your existing basis generally transfers to the replacement contract. The accumulated $25,000 gain remains tax-deferred rather than becoming immediately taxable simply because you changed insurance providers.
This treatment is especially relevant when exchanging a non-qualified annuity, which is typically purchased using money that has already been subject to income tax. The IRS explains the applicable treatment of annuity exchanges in Publication 575, Pension and Annuity Income.
Why Must the Contract Owner Remain the Same?
A qualifying exchange generally requires continuity of ownership between the original and replacement contracts. For annuity-to-annuity exchanges, the same obligee(s) must generally remain on the contract, and an annuity-to-annuity exchange must involve the same insured; ownership or annuitant changes can prevent Section 1035 treatment. Exceptions and contract-specific requirements may apply.
Changing ownership during an exchange can introduce additional tax complications. For example, attempting to transfer an individually owned annuity into another person’s name may prevent the transaction from qualifying under Section 1035.
Before submitting paperwork, confirm that the receiving insurance company has accurately recorded all relevant ownership and annuitant information.
Can You Complete a Partial 1035 Exchange?
A partial 1035 exchange allows you to transfer only part of an existing annuity’s value into another qualifying annuity while retaining the remaining funds in the original contract.
However, partial exchanges require additional care. The IRS provides specific guidance concerning the allocation of investment basis and subsequent distributions involving either contract.
Under Revenue Procedure 2011-38, certain distributions following a partial exchange can affect its tax treatment. Consequently, you should review any planned withdrawals with a qualified tax professional before proceeding.
A partial exchange may provide greater flexibility than replacing an entire contract, but its benefits depend on meeting the applicable IRS requirements and evaluating the financial consequences of maintaining two annuities.
When Does a 1035 Exchange Make Financial Sense (and When Doesn't It)?
A 1035 annuity exchange makes financial sense when the replacement contract offers meaningful long-term advantages that outweigh surrender charges, lost guarantees, and other switching costs. Tax deferral is valuable, but it should never be the sole reason for replacing an existing annuity.
The decision requires comparing what you currently own against what the replacement provides. Annuity Association’s independent fiduciary approach evaluates these trade-offs across more than 80 insurance carriers, helping you determine whether exchanging contracts genuinely supports your retirement objectives.
Evaluating the Costs Against the Benefits
Start by examining any surrender charges attached to your existing annuity. These penalties can significantly reduce the amount available for reinvestment, particularly when your contract is still within its original surrender period.
Next, compare the replacement contract’s potential advantages, including improved interest-crediting caps, lower fees, enhanced income riders, or promotional bonuses. Consider whether these benefits compensate for existing penalties, valuable guarantees you would surrender, and a new surrender schedule that may restrict future access to your money.
For example, a replacement annuity offering improved income features may appear attractive, but giving up an older guaranteed income rider could leave you financially worse off. Similarly, a bonus may not justify switching if the new contract introduces higher ongoing costs or less favorable withdrawal conditions.
Does a 1035 Exchange Make Sense? Scenario Comparison
| Situation | Typically Makes Sense? | Why |
|---|---|---|
| High-fee variable annuity | Potentially | Lower fees or more suitable guarantees may improve long-term outcomes. |
| Maturing MYGA | Often worth considering | The surrender period may be ending, creating an opportunity to compare available rates. |
| Mid-surrender-period contract | Usually not | Significant surrender charges may outweigh the replacement benefits. |
| Valuable legacy income rider | Usually not | Losing favorable guarantees may reduce future retirement income. |
| Consolidating multiple annuities | Sometimes | Fewer contracts may simplify management, provided costs and guarantees remain favorable. |
Applying Annuity Association's 6-D Process
Annuity Association uses its 6-D planning process to evaluate whether a 1035 exchange annuity strategy aligns with your financial circumstances. Two particularly relevant stages are Define and Design.
During the Define stage, advisors establish your retirement income requirements, existing contract benefits, liquidity needs, and financial priorities. The Design stage then evaluates suitable replacement options against your current annuity, accounting for surrender charges, income guarantees, and potential long-term advantages.
For example, if your multi-year guaranteed annuity is approaching maturity, comparing replacement contracts may reveal opportunities to improve your retirement strategy without incurring significant surrender penalties.
You can also review the best annuity rates to explore available options. However, advertised rates should be considered alongside contractual restrictions, insurer financial strength, and your individual retirement needs.
Ultimately, an exchange is worthwhile only when the measurable benefits justify the financial sacrifices involved. Keeping your existing annuity may be the better decision when its guarantees, income provisions, or surrender conditions remain more favorable than available alternatives.
Find Out Whether Your Annuity Exchange Is Worthwhile
Wondering whether exchanging your existing contract would improve your retirement outlook? Annuity Association’s independent fiduciary advisors can compare surrender charges, existing guarantees, and replacement options across more than 80 carriers.
Take the 60-second annuity quiz or schedule a free annuity consultation to explore your options without obligation.
What Are the Tax Implications of a 1035 Exchange?
A properly completed 1035 exchange is a tax-free transfer, which means you owe no federal income tax on the contract’s gains at the time of the exchange. The 1035 exchange tax treatment follows from one fact: because no money is paid to you, nothing is treated as a distribution. The Internal Revenue Service explains how annuity exchanges are handled in Publication 575, Pension and Annuity Income.
Why the 10% Early Withdrawal Tax Does Not Apply
The additional 10% federal tax that can apply to taxable withdrawals before age 59½ generally does not apply to a correctly executed exchange, since a transfer is not a distribution. The gains are not erased, though. They stay inside the replacement contract and are taxed as ordinary income when you eventually take distributions, so the exchange postpones the tax rather than removing it.
When Boot Creates a Taxable Event
Boot is cash or other property you receive in addition to the replacement contract. If any part of the contract value is paid to you directly during the exchange, that portion can be taxable to the extent it represents gain. Accepting a check and depositing it with the new carrier yourself is a common way to create boot by accident, which is why the receiving carrier should handle the transfer directly.
Getting Tax Advice Before You Exchange
Individual tax situations vary, and ownership changes, partial exchanges, and prior withdrawals can all change the outcome. Consult a licensed tax professional before you start an exchange so that they can confirm how it applies to your return.
Keep in mind that annuities are insurance products, not bank deposits, and they are not FDIC insured. Guarantees depend on the claims-paying ability of the issuing insurance company. Annuity Association’s independent fiduciary advisors can compare replacement options across more than 80 carriers, but your tax professional should review the tax side of the decision.
1035 Exchange vs. Surrendering and Repurchasing: Why the Difference Matters
A 1035 exchange preserves tax deferral when you transfer an eligible insurance contract directly into another qualifying contract, while surrendering your existing policy for cash and purchasing a replacement can trigger immediate income taxes. Understanding this distinction is essential before moving your retirement savings.
Although both approaches involve replacing an existing contract, the IRS treats them differently. A properly executed exchange qualifies for favorable treatment under Section 1035, whereas receiving the surrender proceeds personally generally creates a taxable distribution.
Why Surrendering Your Contract Can Be Costly
When you surrender a non-qualified annuity for cash, any accumulated gains are generally subject to ordinary income tax. The taxable amount depends on your contract’s value, investment basis, and individual circumstances.
If you’re younger than 59½, the taxable portion may also be subject to an additional 10% federal tax unless an exception applies. The IRS outlines these rules in Publication 575.
For example, an annuity purchased for $70,000 that has grown to $95,000 contains $25,000 in accumulated gains, assuming no previous adjustments. Surrendering the contract could make those gains taxable, even if you immediately use the proceeds to purchase another annuity.
How a Direct 1035 Exchange Avoids the Problem
A qualifying tax-free transfer allows the accumulated value to move between insurance carriers without treating the transaction as a taxable cash withdrawal. Consequently, income tax on the gains remains deferred, and the additional early-distribution tax generally does not apply because no taxable distribution occurs.
However, tax-free treatment does not eliminate contractual surrender charges or guarantee that the replacement offers better financial terms.
Before initiating an exchange, confirm that the receiving carrier will handle the transfer directly. Taking possession of the money and attempting to reinvest it afterward generally cannot recreate the tax treatment of a properly executed Section 1035 exchange.
Pros and Cons of a 1035 Exchange
A 1035 annuity exchange offers potential tax advantages and greater flexibility when replacing an outdated insurance contract, but it can also introduce new costs and restrictions. Evaluating both sides helps determine whether the replacement supports your retirement objectives.
| Advantages | Disadvantages |
|---|---|
| Preserves tax deferral on accumulated gains | Surrender charges on your existing contract can reduce the amount transferred |
| Access to contracts with lower ongoing fees | A new surrender period can limit access to your funds for several years |
| Income options and guarantees better suited to your current circumstances | Possible loss of grandfathered benefits, favorable guaranteed rates, or valuable income riders |
| Consolidating multiple eligible contracts can simplify account management | Paperwork and carrier coordination can take several weeks |
Advantages of a 1035 Exchange
The primary advantage is preserving tax deferral on accumulated gains while moving into another qualifying contract. Instead of paying income tax when replacing your annuity, you generally postpone taxation until future taxable distributions occur.
An exchange may also provide access to contracts with lower ongoing fees, different income options, or guarantees better suited to your current financial circumstances. For example, someone approaching retirement might prefer predictable income features over the investment options offered by an older variable annuity.
Consolidating multiple eligible contracts can simplify account management and retirement planning. However, consolidation should only proceed when the benefits outweigh any surrender charges or valuable contractual provisions being relinquished.
Disadvantages of a 1035 Exchange
One significant drawback is the possibility of surrender charges on your existing contract. These charges can reduce the amount transferred, potentially offsetting the advantages offered by the replacement annuity.
A new contract may also introduce another surrender period, limiting access to your funds for several years. Additionally, exchanging an older policy could mean forfeiting grandfathered benefits, favorable guaranteed rates, or valuable income riders that are no longer available.
Administrative requirements present another consideration. Processing paperwork, coordinating insurance carriers, and completing the transfer can take several weeks, depending on the companies involved.
Ultimately, the benefits of exchanging depend on your existing contract, available alternatives, and retirement priorities. A qualified fiduciary advisor can compare these factors and help determine whether keeping your current annuity offers greater long-term value.
Frequently Asked Questions About 1035 Exchanges
Is There a 180-Day Rule for a Partial 1035 Exchange?
Under Revenue Procedure 2011-38, a direct partial exchange of an annuity is generally treated as a tax-free 1035 exchange when no amount is received from either contract within 180 days of the transfer. The exception covers payments taken as an annuity over 10 or more years or over one or more lives. Confirm the current guidance with a tax professional before taking any withdrawal.
Can You Do a 1035 Exchange on an Inherited Annuity?
Sometimes, but it is more limited. The IRS has allowed a beneficiary to exchange an inherited non-qualified annuity in a private letter ruling, provided the beneficiary remains the owner and the new contract pays out at least as quickly as the original. Private letter rulings apply only to the taxpayer who requested them, so a tax professional should confirm eligibility.
Can You Do a 1035 Exchange From a Variable Annuity to a Fixed Index Annuity?
Yes. Section 1035 allows an annuity to be exchanged for another annuity regardless of type, so a variable annuity can generally move into a fixed, fixed index, or another variable annuity when the exchange meets IRS requirements. Surrender charges and lost guarantees on the old contract still apply, so compare both contracts before you decide.
Is a 1035 Exchange Reported to the IRS?
Generally, yes. When a carrier reports a 1035 exchange, it uses Form 1099-R with the contract value in Box 1, a taxable amount of zero in Box 2a, and distribution code 6 in Box 7. Receiving a Form 1099-R does not mean the transfer was taxable. Ask a tax professional how to report the exchange on your return.
What Is the Difference Between a 1035 Exchange and a Rollover?
A 1035 exchange generally involves replacing eligible non-qualified annuity or life insurance contracts while preserving tax deferral under Section 1035. A rollover, by contrast, generally transfers retirement savings between qualified accounts or plans, such as IRAs and 401(k)s, under different IRS rules. Both can preserve tax advantages, but their eligibility requirements, procedures, and potential tax consequences differ.
Make an Informed Decision About Your 1035 Exchange
Replacing an annuity that no longer meets your retirement needs should not create unnecessary taxes or compromise valuable financial protections. A 1035 exchange can preserve tax deferral, but the decision depends on whether the replacement contract offers meaningful advantages over your existing policy.
Annuity Association’s independent fiduciary advisors evaluate surrender charges, contract guarantees, and available alternatives across more than 80 insurance carriers to determine whether switching makes financial sense.
Schedule your free annuity consultation to explore your options and make an informed decision about your retirement savings.
Annuity Expert
Jeremiah Konger
PS - Here's 3 ways we can help you learn more about annuities.
1. Watch Videos on How to Identify The Highest Paying Protected Income & Growth Annuities.
2. Watch Videos That Reveal What to Look For When Buying A Protected Growth Annuity.
3. Click Here To Access Our Annuity Review Vault To Compare The Pro's and Con's of Dozens of Annuities.
Annuity Association is the leader in providing Independent Annuity recommendations for protected income, safe growth and other benefits in retirement.
Annuity Association
759 SW Federal Hwy Ste 200H
Stuart, FL 34994
Useful Links
About Annuity Associacion
© Copyrights 2025 by Annuity Association. All Rights Reseved.